Is brand-name medication the same as the generic “equivalent”? Based on my experiences, there is a huge difference. Many doctors, pharmacists, employers, and insurance plans are skeptical without good reason, in the same way that some people don’t believe that PMS really exists.
I am currently taking brand-name Ritalin. My doctor switched me to it several months ago, after being on generic methylphenidate HCl (methylin) for a long time.
In my experience, the generic version was much stronger and harsher than the brand-name one. I am 100% sure that I would be able to tell the difference if I were blindfolded.
Generic methylphenidate HCL was great at helping me concentrate. But it made me jittery, as if I had taken a few shots of espresso. As soon as I would take the medicine, the effect was immediate and strong.
The comedown was also very noticeable. I could tell very clearly when the methylin was wearing down. I would suddenly feel extremely spacey. My mind would be extremely foggy, beyond how it normally is if I’m not on any medication.
I switched to brand-name Ritalin because I was starting to get scared that the methylphedidate HCl was making my concentration worse. My psychiatrist didn’t know much about the differences between the brand name and the generic versions, but, lucky for me, my psychologist had read a lot about it. He told me that my concentration probably wasn’t becoming worse, but that if I was worried about the starting and ending effects being too strong, that brand name Ritalin might be better for me.
He told my psychiatrist about it, and I made the change immediately. I noticed right away that my psychologist was absolutely right. The brand-name Ritalin had a much milder, sloping starting effect, and a gentler comedown. I also felt less jittery and edgy.
I’m just an ADD sufferer/mental patient, so please don’t take this as official medical advice. Remember that I’m not a doctor, and that if you want to switch you should talk to your own doctor.
You might want to do some research online or at the library before asking your doctor, just in case he or she is skeptical. I’ll try to find some articles about this and post links here, when I get a chance.